First jobs matter: Avoiding the underemployment trap June 1, 2018 By Michelle R. Weise, Ph. D. Read Time Strada Article Measuring the Val... Pathways with Pur... Advising Career Connection Navigating Education Value of Education Institute for the... ... We all have heard stories of newly minted college graduates working as baristas or selling clothes at Gap. It’s what economists call underemployment: people doing jobs for which they are overqualified. Generally, however, we dismiss the phenomenon as a relic of the recession or a short-term problem affecting a small number of graduates who will find their footing soon. But underemployment may be far more widespread than we have imagined — affecting up to 43 percent of recent graduates, according to a report. This unprecedented analysis of 4 million unique résumés examines the scope and impact of underemployment on graduates in the years that follow college. It turns out that underemployment can mark the first steps to a permanent professional detour — more than a speed bump on the journey to a prosperous career. The results are troubling, if instructive: With the exception of a few disciplines, such as computer science, engineering and communications, grads who start off underemployed have a higher likelihood of remaining underemployed five and 10 years out. For women, the odds are even worse. Underemployment, we’re learning, is not a short-term challenge. It is a long-term problem with serious financial implications. So how can recent graduates avoid the underemployment trap? Three things matter most: first job, college major and gender. . . . At the 10-year mark, three-quarters of workers who were underemployed as new graduates remained underemployed. . . . The data are clear: If graduates start off underemployed, there is incredible inertia that prevents them from getting out of that rut. The 43 percent of workers who were underemployed in their first job were five times as likely to be underemployed five years later as those who were not underemployed in their first job. The cycle of underemployment is difficult to escape. At the 10-year mark, three-quarters of workers who were underemployed as new graduates remained underemployed. In contrast, individuals who held out for a first job aligned with their academic credentials had a far higher likelihood of staying that way: An overwhelming number of workers who were employed in a college-level job had positions that matched their levels of education five years (87 percent) and 10 years (91 percent) later. First jobs matter. Graduates who avoided the underemployment trap rarely slid into underemployment. At the same time, not all majors are created equal. The risk of underemployment is lowest among most graduates in engineering and computer science, mathematics, and the physical sciences. They are less likely to be underemployed in the first place and, when they are, find it easier to escape the underemployment trap than those majoring in other disciplines. Grads with degrees in security and law enforcement (65 percent); parks and recreation, leisure, and fitness studies (63 percent); and consumer and family sciences psychology (57 percent) have the highest levels of underemployment in their first jobs and are most at risk of being trapped in long-term underemployment. But the most troubling finding was that women are especially vulnerable to underemployment, even women in STEM — science, technology, engineering and math. Women today are more likely to go to college than men, and they graduate at higher rates, but women are also far more likely to start off behind the career curve. Nearly half of all female graduates are in jobs for which they are overqualified, compared with 37 percent of male graduates. And more women are caught in this web five and 10 years out from their first job. These data are especially alarming in an era when women’s wages remain a fraction of men’s (82 percent at last count), when women fill almost half of all jobs but make up just under of a quarter of STEM workers, and when there are fewer female Fortune 500 CEOs than men named James. There is no more pivotal moment in an individual’s career than the handoff between education and work. Recent graduates who are underemployed earn, on average, $10,000 less per year than recent graduates who are appropriately employed. Compounded over time, this financial difference is significant. A wrong move into a first job can sell a graduate short not just for a few years, but for potentially an entire career. The first job is a high-stakes decision, and one that graduates, parents and educators should treat accordingly. Michelle Weise is senior vice president for workforce strategies at Strada Education Network (stradaeducation.org) and chief innovation officer at Strada Institute for the Future of Work, a research and development lab working on solutions to strengthen education-to-employment pathways and build the learning ecosystem of the future. Group 13 Group 11 Group 12 To create a PDF of the webpage, choose in opened window 'Save as PDF' option in 'Destination' select or something like that and click to save or print button. Got it Michelle R. Weise, Ph. D. Author of Long Life Learning Learn More In the news from Strada May 13, 2022 Examples From the Field: University of Minnesota Rochester At the innovative Rochester campus of the University of Minnesota, our vision is to “inspire transformation in higher education through innovations that empower graduates to solve the grand health challenges of the 21st century.” Strada Article BCC May 13, 2022 Examples From the Field: University of Oregon Ducks Rise: Empowering Underrepresented Minorities and Low-Income Students Through Research Internships and Intentional Student Experiences Strada Article BCC May 13, 2022 Examples From the Field: University of Texas System Developing In-Demand Skills Among Undergraduates for Better, More Equitable Post Completion Outcomes Strada Article BCC May 13, 2022 Fulfilling the Promise of Higher Education Access to college isn't enough. Neither is completion of degrees. It's time to focus on outcomes Strada Article BCC April 7, 2022 ‘I Didn’t Know I Had All This in Me’ Credit for prior learning helped Loyce Shelley see herself in a new way — and complete her degree. Strada CAEL Article Adult Learners Career Connection Completion Employers Equity & Oppo... Navigating Education On Purpose Engagement & ... ... March 2, 2022 How Local Partners Can Rebuild the Workforce Equitably Even before the pandemic, employers struggled to find the skilled labor they needed to fill jobs. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... February 23, 2022 Growing Fairly: How to Build Opportunity and Equity in Workforce Development The labor market in the United States faces seemingly contradictory challenges: Many employers have trouble finding qualified applicants for current and future jobs, while millions of Americans are out of work or are underemployed—their paths to living-wage jobs blocked by systemic barriers or lack of adequate skills. Strada Article Innovation in Wor... Adult Learners Career Connection Equity & Oppo... Navigating Education ... February 1, 2022 How Credentials Can Create Opportunity for More People The origin story of Grow With Google, like so many initiatives at the global technology company, begins with data. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Adult Learners Employers Nondegree On Purpose ... January 5, 2022 5 Ways To Integrate Career Connection Into College Experience Recent Strada research points to a striking disparity between first-year students’ aspirations for career planning in their undergraduate years and seniors’ actual experiences. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose Public Viewpoint Research ... December 2, 2021 4 Ways To Build Better Education-Workforce Partnerships More than 18 months into the pandemic, the employment headlines can seem like an algebraic riddle: If U.S. employers are seeking workers to fill 10.9 million jobs, how can 8.4 million workers be unemployed? Strada CAEL Article Connections to Ca... On Purpose ... November 17, 2021 How To Make Sure Education After High School Is Worth the Investment Economist Beth Akers insists she’s not a college debt crisis denier. College is expensive — more than double the cost today compared to the 1980s. And too many students pay too much for it, she said, not only in relation to what they can afford now, but also to what they will earn after graduation. Strada Article Degree and Creden... On Purpose ... November 4, 2021 How To Set Students Up for Success After Graduation As provost and later president at the University of Utah, Ruth Watkins called out the “hollow promise” a university delivers to college students who have access to higher education but leave without completing a degree. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... October 21, 2021 How To Better Serve Latino Students Deborah Santiago’s parents always made clear she and her three siblings would go to college. Strada Article Navigating Education Advising On Purpose Engagement & ... ... October 7, 2021 How the HBCU Experience Builds Leaders Roslyn Clark Artis grew up in southern West Virginia, the only African American in her graduating class. The daughter of a coal miner, she dreamed of becoming a lawyer and applied to every public university in her home state, hoping to find an affordable route to college. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... September 22, 2021 6 Ways Our Conversations Are Shaping What We Know Strada CAEL Inside Track Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... September 8, 2021 6 Ways to Upskill Women for In-Demand Jobs Strada CAEL Inside Track Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose Technology ... August 25, 2021 How To Connect 2-Year Students to a 4-Year School — and a Career Nationwide, about 80 percent of students enrolling in community college say they intend to continue at a four-year college or university to earn a bachelor’s degree. But only 15 percent of community college students achieve that goal within six years. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... August 12, 2021 3 Ways New Philanthropy Models Help More People Faster Strada Article Degree and Creden... On Purpose ... July 29, 2021 Things To Know Now About the Future of Nondegree Credentials Strada Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Employers On Purpose ... July 14, 2021 How Student Supports Can Reverse Enrollment Declines Strada Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... June 22, 2021 ‘Concerned, Worried, and Anxious’ — Insights From Recent High School Grads Strada Article Navigating Education Advising On Purpose ... June 8, 2021 What Will Reconnect Disrupted Learners to Education? Strada Article Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Advising On Purpose ... May 26, 2021 How Community Colleges Can Lead Our Economic Recovery Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... May 11, 2021 Mentoring, Networking, Scholarships — How This Program Pulls Them Together Strada Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... April 27, 2021 How Work Changed for Good in 2020, According to Employers Recruiting, hiring, and training improvements are here to stay, employer survey says Strada Article Connections to Ca... Employers On Purpose ... April 14, 2021 Innovator Spotlight: Project Basta This career exploration and readiness program’s formula for learner success combines social capital, self-discovery to launch career pathways for first-gen grads Strada Article Measuring the Val... Pathways with Pur... Career Connection Completion Navigating Education Spotlight Institute for the... ... April 13, 2021 How To Improve Value of Higher Ed? Increase Career Support Just half of college alumni feel it was worth it to take out loans to attend college, with even lower levels of satisfaction from Black and Latino alumni about their loans. Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... April 1, 2021 Powering Purpose Invest now in community colleges to fuel economic opportunity Strada Article Serving the Adult... Adult Learners Institute for the... ... March 31, 2021 Ready for Work? How To Prep New Grads for Tech Jobs Talent Path’s Learn-and-Earn Model Bridges Skills Gap Between College and Career Strada Article Connections to Ca... Degree and Creden... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ... March 16, 2021 How to Make Online Ed Work for Students Can the pandemic induce higher education to jump-start the future of learning? Strada Article Connections to Ca... Navigating Education Advising Employers On Purpose ...