Students Are Consumers. It’s Time to Treat Them That Way. July 17, 2018 By Carol D’Amico, Ed.D. Read Time Strada Article Research Research Team ... This post was first published by Real Clear Education on July 17, 2018. Your opinion matters. Tell us about your shopping experience. No sooner do we pay for coffee or exit an Apple Store, than we are inundated with questionnaires, surveys, or flash polls that solicit our views as consumers. The ubiquity of mobile computing enables retailers to curate products that pique our interest and experiences that satiate our shifting preferences and behaviors. But consumer data is also helping hospitals understand why certain patients fail to follow post-discharge instructions, and whether patients’ fears might cause them to avoid life-saving procedures. In contrast, the perspectives of education consumers have been all but ignored by most of our nation’s colleges and universities. Institutions have, in turn, been caught flat-footed by the rise of adult learners, who have different needs and expectations than traditional students. If community colleges were more attuned to the needs of student and employer stakeholders, they might have invented “coding bootcamp” ahead of educational upstarts like General Assembly. The challenge stems, in part, from higher education’s organization around inputs over outputs. And it is, perhaps, rooted in higher education’s aversion to using the term “consumer” altogether. We measure the value and quality of an institution through accreditation processes that consider factors like the size of its library, rather than the satisfaction of its graduates. College rankings equate instructional quality with faculty credentials, rather than student outcomes. But students and would-be graduates are, in fact, consumers. They compare options and evaluate the return on potential investments. They are brand-conscious. They are looking to an increasingly diverse array of providers to fulfill their interests and aspirations. This means that even our most venerable institutions now face competition for consumers — and for public investment. Fortunately, there are signs that higher education’s consumer aversion may soon be shifting. Paul Quinn College President Michael Sorrell’s now famous transformation of the university’s football field into a farm is emblematic of a growing willingness to reimagine college for entirely new demands — and learners. Three years ago, we embarked on an ambitious effort to collect perspectives on education from a wide array of Americans: from those with little or no exposure to education after high school all the way to those with post-graduate experiences. We aimed to learn what, if anything, made postsecondary experiences valuable by interviewing students who earned degrees and credentials, as well as those who started college but did not finish. To date, we’ve talked with some 350 Americans a day. That’s 10,000 a month and 250,000 a year. From these interviews a new narrative is emerging. Consumers are telling us that outcomes matter more than inputs. At a time when policymakers and students alike are questioning their return on postsecondary investments, consumers are telling us that career relevance — more so than rankings — shapes their perception of value. In some ways, the power of relevance should not be surprising. Fifty-eight percent of those who attend college do so with the goal of obtaining a job or career outcome. No other reason comes close. In a survey of college freshman, 85 percent indicated they are pursuing higher education to obtain a good job. However, less than 30 percent report having that job upon graduation, and, despite the overwhelming emphasis on relevance, only 26 percent of working Americans with college experience strongly agree that their education is relevant to their work and daily life. Against that backdrop, education consumers might be surprised to learn that the higher education establishment has, at times, been resistant to the concept of “relevance.” Some academics and institutions worry that the “vocationalization” of higher ed might devalue the liberal arts. But a growing body of evidence suggests that rigor and relevance may not be at odds, after all. President Sorrell has urged a new conversation focused on “reality, rather than work-based education.” . . . 58% of those who attend college do so with the goal of obtaining a job or career outcome. No other reason comes close. . . . Columnist George Anders wrote an entire book on the “surprising power of a (useless) liberal arts education” to lead students to cutting-edge jobs. Regardless of one’s interpretation, the magnitude of these data presents a clear call to action. Institutions of higher education will have to think differently about quality and value and to align their approach to education with the needs and desires of the consumers they exist to serve. As it is, there is a disconnect between what consumers want and expect from postsecondary education and what they are receiving. Carol D’Amico served in the U.S. Department of Education as assistant secretary for adult and vocational education, and as executive vice president and chancellor of Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana. She now serves as Executive Vice President for Mission Advancement and Philanthropy with Strada Education Network. Group 13 Group 11 Group 12 To create a PDF of the webpage, choose in opened window 'Save as PDF' option in 'Destination' select or something like that and click to save or print button. Got it Carol D’Amico, Ed.D. Learn More Latest From Research April 1, 2024 State Opportunity Index The State Opportunity Index was developed to help states build a stronger connection between education after high school and equitable pathways to opportunity so students realize the full value of their education and employers have the workforce they need to fill high-demand jobs. March 29, 2024 State Opportunity Index – Mamie Voight Mamie Voight, president and CEO of the Institute for Higher Education Policy, on how states can use State Opportunity Index data to identify what is working within higher education and what needs to improve. March 29, 2024 State Opportunity Index – Michael Collins Michael Collins, vice president of the Center for Racial Economic Equity at Jobs for the Future, on how the State Opportunity Index tells a more nuanced story of the data surrounding the value of education after high school. March 29, 2024 State Opportunity Index – Wil Del Pilar Wil Del Pilar, senior vice president of The Education Trust, on how the State Opportunity Index helps measure whether policies and practices are actually benefiting the students they were designed to support. February 21, 2024 Talent Disrupted: An Interview With Strada CEO Stephen Moret ‘Colleges and universities, states, and our country can do more to help prepare students for the critical transition from college to the labor market.’ February 21, 2024 Talent Disrupted New research highlights what states and institutions can do to help more graduates secure college-level jobs. January 25, 2024 A Salute to Our Mentors The gift of time. A recognition of talent. A helping hand. How our mentors helped shape us as people and professionals. December 21, 2023 Strada Education Foundation Appoints Heather McKay to Direct Institute for the Future of Work Strada Education Foundation Appoints Heather McKay to Direct Institute for the Future of Work December 12, 2023 Community college, biotech companies partner to prepare students for careers At the heart of MiraCosta College’s Increase Diversity, Equity, and Advancement in Biotechnology (IDEA-BTEC) program, funded in part by a $400,000 grant from Strada Education Foundation, is a unique partnership between the college and two local biotech employers: Sterogene Bio-Separations and Open Biopharma Research and Training Institute. November 1, 2023 Community college, dental insurer come together to address dental hygienist shortage The community college learning lab and dental clinic is now a newly refurbished space where dental hygiene students refine their technique on mannequins outfitted with realistic incisors, molars, and cuspids. The clinic was remodeled through a partnership with Delta Dental of Rhode Island and supported by a $400,000 grant from Strada Education Foundation. September 27, 2023 Employment data, postsecondary data should work together, Strada urges The letter was delivered in response to the department’s request for information regarding the disclosure of confidential wage records under the department’s regulations governing the confidentiality and disclosure of state unemployment compensation data. Strada also included specific recommendations for regulatory amendments. September 19, 2023 Webinar: Value of community colleges extends beyond completion rates Copy Report indicates both success and need for improvement in meeting students’ varied goals September 19, 2023 Strada Appoints Kathleen Smith as Senior Vice President of Federal Government Relations Veteran education policy advocate brings extensive federal experience to shape policy solutions that strengthen pathways to opportunity September 12, 2023 New Strada grant aids those who help students and families complete FAFSA A new and improved Free Application for Federal Student Aid expected late this year should provide opportunities for more students and their families to access money to pay for college. Yet the transition to this new form presents unprecedented challenges for those who work to help students complete it. September 7, 2023 The Value of Community Colleges: Recent Students’ Motivations and Outcomes To better understand the value community colleges provide to individuals and communities, we need to acknowledge the range of needs they serve. September 6, 2023 New study assesses recent community college students’ views on value of their education According to new Strada Education Foundation research, community college attendees who complete an associate degree or successfully transfer to a four-year institution value their education at rates comparable to or higher than recent bachelor’s degree completers. However, researchers found first-generation students rated the value of their community college education about 20 percentage points lower than those who are not first-generation students.